Back to Top

Category: Britain

Carp Diem

Rejoin EU – Carpe Diem

Here is our paper on “Rejoin EU – Why Delay is Dangerous”. Please sign our petition where you are able to download your copy for free.

Then mail your MP and other influencers. Ideally print a copy and pop in an envelope with a personal note. We know that printed letters are given more weight than e-mails. If you need a short letter to add, we have offered you one on the petition.

And / or you can also e-mail the paper. Your MP’s e-mail has the format of firstname.lastname.mp@parliament.uk so, for example, Andy Burnham is andy.burnham.mp@parliament.uk The full text of the paper follows and a QR code for sharing.

Rejoin EU – Why delay is dangerous

Executive Summary

Andy Burnham’s announcement on Rejoining the EU is welcome after years of parliamentary paralysis on Brexit.  Brexit is proven dead yet continues to kill Britain slowly across all metrics: economic, sociological, political, legal, ethical, technological and environmental.  Most politicians agree that we must Reboot Britain, in part by applying to Rejoin the EU.  However, we must begin now, and not in the mid 2030s.  Delay is dangerous for four principal reasons, expanded in this paper:

  • Business damage:  The damage from Brexit will be complete, much of it irreversible.  
  • Moral Hazard:  7-10 years of continued uncertainty provides an extended opportunity for bad actors inside and outside Britain to infect our politics. Multiple scenarios are possible across the decade.  One of the most potent is some kind of merger / acquisition between Restore and Reform or The Conservatives.
  • Business and public confidence:  Prolonged uncertainty will be catastrophic for UK  business confidence and inward investment. Whilst nobody liked the debates during the 2016 referendum, there is zero appetite for a decade of debate about Rejoin.
  • Overton Windows cleaned:  Public interest and pressure has been attenuated by parliamentary silence on Brexit and the fact that there is no coherent movement to Rejoin the EU.  Instead, the Overton window has been shifted onto the ‘offspring of Brexit’ e.g. cost of living, NHS, social care, migration and parochial / identity political issues.  All these issues have at least some roots in Brexit.

We must prepare Britain for change via a series of national conversations about ‘A Better Britain in a Better Europe for a Better World’.  We began these in 2025, and all the data is publicly available to support an application to Rejoin.  Action can come from a majority decision in Parliament, a General Election promise or a referendum.  Even senior observers on all sides point out that ‘logical incrementalism’ on Brexit, in other words, more small slow steps, will not deliver the needed growth in Britain.

Most British people now accept that Brexit has broken Britain across all the STEEPLE factors. Externally, we live in a perilous world in terms of global conflicts, security, unfettered and unregulated AI, the march of populism and ‘strong man’ leaders.  All of these add weight to the argument that we should align with our partners in Europe now.

European leaders have stated that the door is open, we could return quickly and on similar or the same terms. Caution never delivered growth.  Perilous times need reliable allies.  So, we must lead, not lag.  Brexit costs UK between 4.5 and 8% of GDP or up to £240 billion every year, or a much-needed uplift to defence, a national care service, etc.

Delay is dangerous

The risks in delaying an approach to Rejoin EU via an Article 49 letter to the 2030s are:

  • Recovering Britain’s resilience

Brexit costs Britain and its citizens between 4.5 and 8% or up to £240 BILLIONevery year. This is in line with Government predictions made before people voted for Brexit, which ranged from about 3% to an eye-watering 12% for a no deal Brexit. For comparison, it took just a 3% hit on GDP to crash UK’s economy in 2008. This itself led to a decade of austerity, which helped to swing the Brexit vote in 2016, alongside a series of false promises about zero downsides, only sunny uplands.

Whilst the business impacts have largely been incremental, they have been continuous.  Whilst larger enterprises can and have pivoted towards different markets, many have decided either not to export, to move to European bases or simply to cease trading.  Some of these decisions are one time moves.  By the mid 2030s, business damage from Brexit  will be complete, much of it irreversible.  Having undone 40 years of integration, many if not most will be reluctant or unable to switch back again.

However, this is not just an economic argument.  The book Reboot Britain outlines the impacts and opportunities right across the STEEPLE (Social, Technical, Economic, Environmental, Political, Legal and Ethical) factors.  In terms of Britain’s resilience, Brexit is rather like trying to swim the English Channel with a 20 kg block of concrete around your neck.


  • Moral Hazards from inside and afar

7-10 years of continued uncertainty provides an extended opportunity for bad actors within and outside Britain to get involved in our politics.  Since Andy Burnham’s announcement, we have already noted an upsurge of disinformation from former Vote Leave figures and in the right-wing press.  Multiple political scenarios are possible across that extended window. 

One of the most potent is some kind of merger / acquisition between Restore and Reform and / or The Conservatives.  At this point, Nigel Farage is possibly the main obstacle to Rupert Lowe’s alignment with Reform UK.  Farage is now a net vote loser for Reform UK.  Pending changes within the Conservative party, other alliances of convenience are possible.  This would be a hammer blow to a second Labour term and potentially any progressive alliances between Lib Dems, Greens etc.

Political fluidity, disruptive strategy and expediency may also affect Labour, the Lib Dems and Greens.  In short, nothing can be ruled out across such a long period.  As argued above, the time for action is now.

Over the next 7-10 years, The SNP, Sinn Fein and Plaid Cymru may also have taken steps along the road to independence.  This is itself a further validation of Brexit’s destructive impact on The United Kingdom.  We have ourselves witnessed the beginnings of the so-called Celtic alliance in the Houses of Parliament.

We know that Russia has in the past decade devoted considerable resources to disrupting the EU and the UK’s relationship to the Union. Every further year of hesitancy from the British government on the European question gives further opportunities for mischief-making to Vladimir Putin. And we know that he has potential sympathisers among the pro-Brexit wing of British politics.

  • Business and public confidence 

Prolonged uncertainty on Brexit over the next decade will be catastrophic for business confidence, staffing and inward investment. We already know that foreign direct investment (FDI) inflows dropped by 37 per cent between 2016 and 2022, as multinational companies relocated operations to the EU for single market access, and external investors diverted their cash elsewhere.  In terms of employment, agriculture, healthcare and hospitality are amongst the sectors that have all encountered labour shortages, resulting in higher operating costs while restricting output. Fishing, another key industry which voted for Brexit, and which was weaponised by Nigel Farage in 2016, has lived to regret it.

Whilst nobody liked the debates that were thrown up by the 2016 referendum, there is zero appetite for another decade long mass debate about Brexit. We are already seeing a resurgence of “Project Fear”, but this time being run by Vote Leave acolytes and far right media outlets.  This will become a new normal and thus the longer we delay the decision to apply to Rejoin, the more toxic the narrative will become.

By opening the conversation now, Andy Burnham may well find that Brexit becomes a long-term malignant tumour in public discourse.  Without surgical removal, it may claim further victims, having taken the heads of six Prime Ministers in ten years through its cancerous effects.  Brexit has literally consumed all its offspring.  It is a matter of time before it claims another scalp … This gruesome graphic sums up the grim reality.

  • Overton windows cleaned

There is no appreciable or sizeable movement to Rejoin the EU in 2026, given the fragmentation of the various Rejoin movements (akin to Indonesia – 17 000 islands, many unoccupied and a few bigger ones who compete for the hearts, minds and bank balances of their followers}.  There is no reason to suppose it would be any bigger or better by the mid 2030s.

There is also a complete lack of agreement amidst the various ‘islands’ on both ends (what is the destination?) and means of reaching the destination (the journey).  We are dealing with what is often characterised as a wicked problem.   If a series of national conversations are to be held on the topic of ‘A Better Britain in a Better Europe for a Better World’, it will need skilful leadership to achieve the required levels of convergence for a more United Kingdom.  We have already offered such support  on the Organisation Development (OD) disciplines and large-scale event design implications of this (Open Space Tech etc) to various MPs in this regard.

Public pressure on Brexit and Europe has also been attenuated by parliamentary silence on the matter, e.g. in the 2024 General Election.  The Overton window has moved towards the ‘offspring’ of Brexit e.g. cost of living, NHS, social care, migration and parochial / identity political issues.  All have their roots in Brexit, as this multiple cause and effect model shows.  A properly designed national conversation would bring Brexit back into a controlled and civil dialogue about the issues that matter to people, politicians and politics.

Professor Sir John Curtice stated that public opinion had shifted despite a relative silence from many parties and “therefore, if you were to start to make the argument … you should be able to move the dial further”.  He warned of the dangers of delay as the salience of Brexit declines in public consciousness.  Once an Overton Window has been ‘cleansed’ it is very unlikely that the same issues will appear in it again … unless done in deliberate and controlled manner.

Summary

in summary, Britain has fared badly, post Brexit. Brexit has damaged our economy, split the UK and its component parts and reduced us to a minor player on the teetering edge of a significant political entity, this at a time of enormous socio-economic pressure from America, Russia and the Far East. It is estimated that we are losing 4.5-8% of our annual GDP.  This looks set continue under the last two years of a Trump Presidency as it may turn to easier targets outside the USA, whilst the Democrats naturally focus on the domestic agenda.

The current British government has indicated a willingness to consider the issue of rejoining Europe in some form, but so far has not indicated any urgency in the matter. The lack of urgency is counter-productive, as further delay will only harden the damage already caused to our ability to create growth and put the UK back on track as a successful and prosperous country.

The UK Labour government currently has an enormous majority in Parliament and could take the necessary action of a unilateral nature.  Inaction presents a clear and present danger to the UK and its standing in the world.

Recommendation

That this paper is submitted to all progressive MPs and political thinkers, emphasising the urgency of a move to rejoin Europe and the European Union.

We are available to assist with the formulation of a strategy and event designs to deliver a national conversation about a Better Britain in a Better Europe for a Better World across a period of 3-6 months, starting in 2017.

Peter Cook – Reboot Britain.

Greg Newman.

Colonel Terence Knott – President, Amicale Europe Pays de Fayence.

November 16th, 2026

Branson Line Up Shot

Wannabe?

Wannabe or seriously fun contender? You decide. Our latest post on Substack. Please subscribe and share.

Substack – Head of Yes at Virgin

Compared with the usual suspects I believe I am uniquely qualified for this job. Importantly I’d use the £75 000 wage to supercharge our efforts to Reboot Britain.

  • Entrepreneur of 32 years standing focusing on leadership, innovation and creativity.
  • Excellent content creator focusing on astonishing people and the art of storytelling.
  • Virgin Prize winner and author of book for Bloomsbury with Richard Branson’s input via an interview
  • Mature but alive and kicking! I bring considerable experience, wisdom and depth to the position
  • I fully understand the Virgin ethos having volunteered for them for 3 years.
  • Considerable international experience.
  • I am a very skilled interviewer.
  • I plan to use the money to help build a better Britain in a better Europe for a better World through influencing our political leaders of all colours.

Brexit Begat Boats and Racism

It’s a kind of magic …

I was told by my MP that Andy Burnham was a magician and that if we got rid of Keir Starmer, all would be well with Brexit. Turns out she was wrong and we have merely continued down the road of the Fabian Society / Logical Incrementalism. I was called up by Dubai TV to explain more last week and made a full film on my thoughts, as, inevitably a TV piece gets cut to a few soundbites. Let’s see the Burnham magic applied, not continuity Starmer.

Please like, subscribe and share

That said, the Remain movement have not changed their spots. We have Jon Danzig proclaiming that we cannot contemplate Rejoin until we have aligned all the political parties in that vision. I cannot recall a time when that has ever happened, including on the vexed question of whether water is wet …

And Niall Ó Conghaile also subscribes to the “Catholic” view that we have not atoned suffciently for our Brexit sins yet. Of course, cakeism is a problem with the “Rule Britannia” outlook of some Rejoiners, but this does not mean we should not apply to Rejoin the EU as a priority.

Champion fence sitter, and friend of Lord David Frost, Prof Anand Menon is also saying that support for Rejoining drops away when you factor the Euro and Schengen into the picture. All such things are above his pay grade in so far that he is not at the negotiating table. The conversation to Rejoin will be a series of trade offs and NONE of us will be at the table. It’s both stupid and presumptuous to factor all the obstacles to progress in at the beginning. Academics can only tell you about things as they are and give some history lessons. They know nothing about the impact of leadership on the Overton Window. Our only job is to create the political momentum to apply to Rejoin as an urgent priority, NOT to imagine that we are at the negotiating table. No wonder Remain lost three times (two elections and a referendum). We are still gold plating the strategy that lost.

With people like this in our corner, who needs enemies? I wrote about the OD (Organisation Development) problems of Remain / Rejoin some years ago under Indonesia. I’m disappointed to report that this is a hardy perennial, needing radical treatment. I’m available for hire if the various big islands of Indonesia need some group therapy although somewhat doubtful that they will take me up on my offer.

Here’s the Dubai TV piece.

Join us on Wed 28 October at 8pm – 8.45pm on ZOOM for a social gathering cum next steps dialogue with like minded people from across Europe. Put the date in your diary NOW, Connect to us on all platforms via Linktree.

I

IZAL Brexshit

Flush Brexit

I listened to a retrospective on Izal Toilet paper the other day on The BBC’s “Sliced Bread – Toast”. It was fascinating in its own right, not least because I used to buy boxes of product on the internet to use in creativity programmes for corporate executives. But it was to the Brexit connections that I was drawn. Let me summarise some of the key points from the programme.

Izal Medicated Toilet Paper was invented by accident in 1885 after they noticed that one of the by-products of coal processing had antiseptic qualities. Izal disinfectant was eventually followed by Izal toilet paper. It was positioned as the only safe way to protect yourself against bum germs. Izal claimed to help prevent influenza, typhus, even malaria, having been launched shortly after the Spanish Flu outbreak in the 1920s. Sadly, the claims made about the product’s efficacy were completely false, based on the disinfectant rather than the toilet paper. I was reminded of Boris and Nigel’s claims about Brexit, which have been shown to be completely false.

Interestingly the programme plotted the steady decline of Izal as a brand, following the advent of soft toilet paper in the 1950s. People literally stuck to Izal in the face of the carbolic smell, the fact that the shit slid off the paper onto your fingers and the bum cuts that resulted from this unyielding product. Some preferred to use newspaper to wipe their anuses or ani. In Yorkshire there was resistence to toilet tissue, based on the fact that some Yorkshire men felt that softness was seen as a bit ‘gay’ (used in its modern context here). However more cosmopolitan wipers in London adopted the soft tissue product. Much the same as Brexit really with more countrified areas voting for Brexit and cities rejecting it. Johnson and Farage projected an alpha male view onto the softer minds in British society of “taking back control” and “avenging forin invaders”. It’s all so transparent and false at the same time.

Izal limped on however. A Government commission even concluded that Izal must continue to be used in all public places, forgetting to mention that the main reason for this was that nobody wanted to steal it. Izal continued to be popular with an older demographic who preferred to cut their arses, have shit on their fingers and smell like Jeyes Fluid rather than clean up. The Brexit mind is similar, in so far that people want things to be like they were, a golden age of the 1950’s where men were men, typhoid made a man of you, women were quiet, pints were in straight glasses Winston cigarettes made you cool and so on. The Raise the Colours idiots exemplify this faux nostalgia,

The Brexit Psyche
The Brexit Psyche

In conclusion “Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way” … Pink Floyd.

Postscript : “IZAL was nearly as slippery as Farage”. Grumpy Mirror Pensioner

Once in a lifetime

Once in a lifetime


Once in a lifetime you get a chance to do something amazing. If you do one thing today, watch this film interview. Yes, it’s long but it’s vital.

For most of you, you can help by sharing this post and the videos that accompany it. Find them at at EU TUBE.

For those of you who live in Clacton, Vote Serious : Vote for The Rejoin EU Party on Thursday 13th August – to break the Parliamentary Paralysis. Bin the Bin and vote to “take back control” of Britain.

If you only have a minute, watch this one minute trailer and share widely:

Full fact Brexit

Adrian, a business advisor, freelance lecturer on international business and entrepreneurship and provider of due diligence services, has written this absolutely brilliant fact check of the comments made at the leaders’ debate we organised recently. I had puposely not wished to use our airtime to go down Leave rabbit holes and many of the online comments made at the time did seek to correct the inaccuracies and disinformation. But Adrian’s piece goes well beyond the time available at the time. Thank you so much. I remain grateful to Bob for conducting a cordial debate when others prefer GBH as a weapon of change. Find the You Tube video here and Adrian’s fact check below. It’s a long read but well worth it.



Dear Peter – It takes effort for me to do the back up research there are a number of factual claims by Bob Lidden and Co that can be checked. Some are matters of opinion (which can’t really be fact-checked), while others are objective claims that can.

ClaimAssessmentNotes
Labour is secretly trying to reverse Brexit by stealth❌ Opinion/speculationPolitical interpretation rather than a factual claim.
The EU Partnership Bill allows rejoining parts of the Single Market without parliamentary legislation⚠️ Needs verificationThis is a legal claim that can be checked against the Bill.
Labour won only 33% of the vote in 2024✅ CorrectLabour received about 33.7% of votes.
OBR predicted a 4% GDP loss based on assuming 0.25% lower productivity growth per year⚠️ Partly misleadingThe OBR does estimate around a 4% long-run reduction in productivity/GDP from Brexit, but this isn’t simply “made up”—it’s based on extensive trade/productivity literature rather than a single arbitrary assumption.
Recent studies claiming an 8% GDP loss are flawed because they compare the UK mainly with the US⚠️ MisleadingDepends on which study he means. Most modern estimates use synthetic control methods and compare the UK with many advanced economies.
Public sector plus “state-directed” companies now account for 60–65% of the economy❌ No evidenceThis appears to be his own estimate. I know of no official source supporting this figure.
UK is approaching Soviet levels of state control❌ Opinion/hyperboleNot a factual claim.
European Commission makes the laws, not the European Parliament❌ MisleadingThe Commission proposes legislation, but legislation normally requires approval by both the European Parliament and the Council of Ministers.
Citizens cannot “sack” the European Commission⚠️ Partly trueCommissioners are not directly elected, but they are nominated by elected governments and approved by the elected Parliament, which can also force the Commission to resign via a motion of censure.
Lisbon Treaty created the EU as a sovereign nation❌ FalseThe Lisbon Treaty did not create a sovereign state. It amended the treaties governing an international organisation. Member states remained sovereign under international law.
Eurozone countries have no feasible legal route to leave the euro⚠️ Mostly trueThere is no explicit treaty mechanism for leaving only the euro while remaining in the EU.
Around 70% of UK laws came from the EU❌ False / greatly exaggeratedMultiple studies have found much lower figures. Estimates vary enormously depending on methodology, but 70% has repeatedly been criticised as inaccurate.
ECB exceeded its mandate buying government bonds⚠️ DisputedGerman constitutional lawyers argued this. However, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled the programmes were lawful and within the Treaties.
UK led the international response to the 2022 invasion of Ukraine because it was outside the EU⚠️ Opinion mixed with factThe UK was certainly one of the leading supporters of Ukraine, but it’s speculative to say this was only possible because Brexit had occurred.

Two particularly weak claims

These stand out as the least supported:

1. “70% of UK laws came from the EU.”

This is an old Eurosceptic statistic that has been repeatedly challenged by constitutional scholars. Depending on how one counts legislation, estimates have ranged from under 15% to around 50%, but 70% is generally regarded as an exaggeration.


2. “The Lisbon Treaty created the EU as a sovereign nation.”

This is simply incorrect.

The Lisbon Treaty:

  • amended existing treaties;
  • gave the EU legal personality;
  • did not abolish the sovereignty of member states;
  • explicitly recognised that powers not conferred on the EU remain with the member states (principle of conferral).

Even strong critics of the EU usually describe it as a supranational organisation, not a sovereign country.


Claims that deserve a careful look

Some of his economic arguments are more nuanced than simply true or false.

For example, when he criticises the OBR’s estimate of a roughly 4% long-run reduction in UK productivity/GDP after Brexit, he’s right that it’s a model-based projection rather than an observed fact. However, it’s misleading to imply the figure is arbitrary: the OBR’s estimate is grounded in a substantial body of empirical research linking trade openness and productivity.

Similarly, his criticism of the “8% GDP” estimate depends entirely on which study he’s referring to. Some recent studies do use sophisticated synthetic-control methods rather than simply comparing the UK with the US, so dismissing them as “just comparing us to America” would not fairly represent their methodology.

If you’re trying to assess Bob Lidden as a speaker, I’d say his presentations combine:

  • factual statements that are broadly correct,
  • disputed interpretations presented as facts,
  • and a number of assertions for which little or no supporting evidence is provided.

I can also go through the transcript line by line, rating every factual claim as True / Mostly true / Misleading / False / Opinion, with references explaining each judgement. That produces a much more comprehensive fact-check.

yes please

Absolutely. I’ll treat it as I would a policy institute report: separating fact, interpretation, opinion, and unsupported assertion. I’ll also indicate where there is a genuine academic debate rather than one side simply being wrong.

Overall impression

Bob Lidden is clearly knowledgeable about banking and monetary policy, but throughout this discussion he often:

  • states contested interpretations as settled facts;
  • omits important context;
  • mixes legal facts with political opinion;
  • occasionally makes claims that are simply unsupported by evidence.

I’d probably score the factual reliability around 6/10. Much of what he says has a kernel of truth but is often overstated.


00:36

“Reset equals rejoin.”

Verdict: ❌ Opinion

This is political rhetoric.

The UK-EU “reset” announced by Labour is not rejoining the EU.

Whether it is a stepping stone towards rejoining is speculation.


01:04

“The EU Partnership Bill allows this without legislation going before Parliament.”

Verdict: ⚠ Needs checking

This is a precise legal claim.

It depends on exactly which Bill he means.

If true, it would require examining delegated powers within the legislation.

This is one I’d verify directly.


01:28

Labour only won 33% of the vote.

Verdict: ✅ Correct

Labour won roughly 33.7%.

No issue.


02:03

Costa’s 4% GDP figure.

Verdict: ⚠ Partly misleading

He is referring to António Costa repeating estimates similar to those of the Office for Budget Responsibility.

The OBR estimate is indeed around 4% lower long-run productivity/GDP.

Where Bob becomes misleading is suggesting it came from simply assuming productivity would fall by 0.25%.

The OBR did not invent that figure.

It drew on decades of international evidence linking trade intensity and productivity.

You can disagree with the modelling.

But it isn’t arbitrary.


03:20

The latest 8% figure compares us mainly with the US.

Verdict: ❌ Probably false

The major 2025 Stanford work by Nicholas Bloom and colleagues doesn’t simply compare Britain with America.

It constructs a synthetic comparison using numerous advanced economies.

So this criticism doesn’t accurately describe the methodology.


04:03

UK economy still has high regulation, high taxes and high state intervention.

Verdict: ⚠ Mostly opinion

Reasonable political judgement.

Not fact-checkable.


04:27

State-directed sector means around 60–65% of economy is under state control.

Verdict: ❌ Unsupported

I’ve never seen any economist produce anything close to this estimate.

ONS data certainly doesn’t.

It appears entirely his own calculation.


05:05

Comparable with Soviet Union statistics.

Verdict: ❌ Hyperbole

No evidence.

Pure rhetoric.


06:05

European Commission makes the laws.

Verdict: ❌ Misleading

Reality:

Commission:

  • proposes legislation

European Parliament:

  • amends
  • votes

Council:

  • votes

Without Parliament, legislation normally cannot pass.


06:22

You cannot sack the European Commission.

Verdict: ⚠ Half true

Citizens don’t directly elect Commissioners.

However:

  • elected governments nominate them
  • elected Parliament approves them
  • Parliament can dismiss the Commission.

So this oversimplifies.


16:55

Lisbon Treaty created the EU as a sovereign nation.

Verdict: ❌ False

This is probably his weakest factual statement.

The Lisbon Treaty:

  • amended treaties;
  • gave legal personality;
  • did not create a sovereign country.

Member states remained sovereign.


18:18

Countries cannot leave the euro.

Verdict: ⚠ Mostly true

No treaty provides a straightforward mechanism.

Lawyers generally agree there’s no clean legal route.


19:07

Around 70% of British law came from the EU.

Verdict: ❌ False

This statistic has been examined repeatedly.

Different studies produce:

  • around 13%
  • around 30%
  • sometimes 40–50%

depending how one counts.

No serious constitutional expert accepts a flat 70%.


20:20

ECB exceeded its mandate.

Verdict: ⚠ Genuine legal dispute

German constitutional lawyers argued this.

However:

The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled the bond-buying programmes lawful.

So Bob presents one side of a legal dispute.


30:07

Amazon Luxembourg books UK sales.

Verdict: ⚠ Historically true but dated

Amazon did channel European profits through Luxembourg.

Tax rules have changed substantially.

The broad point is fair.

The implied current scale probably isn’t.


31:07

£15 billion corporation tax lost in 2017.

Verdict: ❌ Unsupported

I’ve never seen HM Treasury estimate this.

Needs evidence.


34:18

CPTPP worth only 0.08%.

Verdict: ✅ Correct

Government modelling estimated roughly 0.08% GDP over the long term.

Peter is correct here.


41:18

Good Friday Agreement was used to frustrate Brexit.

Verdict: ❌ Opinion

This is political interpretation.

Not fact.


43:30

“I’d rip up the Windsor Framework.”

Opinion.

Nothing to fact-check.


46:16

No referendum needed to rejoin.

Verdict: ✅ Correct

Legally:

Parliament could legislate.

Politically:

Very controversial.

Legally:

Correct.


52:19

EU sold Ukraine down the river in 2014.

Verdict: ⚠ Highly contested

He is referring to the Minsk agreements.

Many historians criticise them.

Many also argue they bought Ukraine valuable time.

Not an objective fact.


54:05

Britain could only lead Ukraine because Brexit happened.

Verdict: ❌ Unsupported

No evidence.

Counterfactual.

Impossible to prove.


56:18

Japanese manufacturers leaving because of EV transition rather than Brexit.

Verdict: ⚠ Partly true

It’s both.

For example:

  • Honda cited global restructuring.
  • Nissan repeatedly warned Brexit increased costs.
  • Toyota likewise expressed concerns.

Most economists regard Brexit as one factor among several.


Overall accuracy table

TopicRating
Election figures✅ Accurate
OBR modelling⚠ Partly misleading
GDP studies❌ Misrepresented
Lisbon Treaty❌ False
70% laws❌ False
Commission makes laws❌ Misleading
ECB legality⚠ Legitimate dispute
Corporation tax losses❌ Unsupported
State control 65%❌ Unsupported
Ukraine⚠ Opinion mixed with fact
Brexit economic effects⚠ Selective use of evidence

My biggest concerns

If I were reviewing this for publication, I’d put red flags next to five statements:

  1. “Lisbon created a sovereign EU nation.” – False.
  2. “70% of UK laws came from Brussels.” – Repeatedly debunked.
  3. “60–65% of the UK economy is under state control.” – No credible evidence.
  4. “The Commission makes EU laws.” – Incomplete and misleading description of the legislative process.
  5. His dismissal of the OBR and recent GDP studies – He criticises them without accurately representing their methodologies.

One thing I would say in his favour is that he isn’t simply inventing statistics out of thin air. Most of his arguments reflect a longstanding Eurosceptic school of thought. The problem is that he often presents contested interpretations as if they are settled facts, without acknowledging the substantial body of contrary evidence from mainstream economists, constitutional lawyers, and political scientists. That’s an important distinction when assessing the reliability of his claims.

and the EU stopping AI?

That exchange is actually a good example of how both speakers simplify a more complicated reality.

Bob says:

“I thought they’d come up with some fat draft of restrictions… which had AI people in the EU doing what we can still do.”

Peter replies:

“I wish perhaps the EU would almost do a little bit more of that.”

Is Bob correct?

Partly, but it overstates what the EU has done.

The EU has not “stopped AI”.

What it has done is pass the European Union AI Act, the world’s first comprehensive AI law.

The Act:

  • Bans a small number of AI uses considered unacceptable risks, such as:
    • social scoring by governments (similar to concerns about China’s system);
    • certain forms of manipulative AI;
    • some real-time biometric identification by law enforcement, subject to exceptions.
  • Strictly regulates “high-risk” AI systems, such as those used in:
    • healthcare,
    • recruitment,
    • education,
    • critical infrastructure.
  • Places transparency obligations on general-purpose AI models (such as ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, etc.), particularly the most powerful models.

It does not prohibit companies from developing AI.


Does it make AI development harder?

Yes.

Most AI companies—including European ones—accept that compliance costs are real.

Critics argue:

  • more paperwork;
  • slower innovation;
  • higher compliance costs;
  • Europe risks falling behind the US and China.

Supporters argue:

  • public trust increases;
  • fewer dangerous deployments;
  • clearer legal framework;
  • better protection for consumers.

That’s a genuine policy debate.


Was Sunak trying to do the opposite?

Peter’s comment about Rishi Sunak is broadly fair.

The UK deliberately chose a much lighter-touch approach.

Rather than introducing an AI Act, the UK government preferred:

  • existing regulators;
  • voluntary commitments;
  • encouraging investment;
  • making Britain attractive for AI companies.

That doesn’t mean “no regulation”, but considerably less than the EU.


Is Bob’s implication that AI can’t be developed in Europe true?

No.

Companies like:

  • Mistral AI
  • Aleph Alpha
  • Helsing

are all developing frontier AI in Europe.

OpenAI, Google, Microsoft and Anthropic also continue operating in Europe.

So the AI Act hasn’t “stopped AI”.


Was Peter right that “good regulation” is needed?

That’s largely a value judgement, not something that can be fact-checked.

Economists and computer scientists are split.

Some argue:

  • regulation is essential before AI becomes more powerful.

Others argue:

  • regulation should come later because early regulation entrenches existing large firms and slows innovation.

Verdict

Bob’s suggestion that the EU has effectively “stopped AI” or is preventing Europeans from doing things people elsewhere can do is an exaggeration.

A fairer summary would be:

The EU has introduced the world’s most comprehensive AI regulation. It increases compliance costs and restricts certain high-risk uses of AI, but it does not prohibit AI development or deployment generally.

That’s a much more accurate description of the current situation.

Lecter

The Wasted Years

I was looking back at an article I wrote in March 2016 foreshadowing the Brexit Referendum. Some other people remarked at its accuracy in terms of what we actually got from Brexit, so I feel no great need to rewrite the piece or even to write something new on the 10th anniversary of the Brexit referendum. Find the article at Shall I Stay or Shall I Go.

“Extraordinarily well worded”. Steve Rouse, Leader of Swindon for Europe.

“Still relevant – seems like the more things change, the more they stay the same… 😖” Greg Newman, Northern Ireland.

The three Brexit promises of taking back control of our money, borders and laws have been shown to be utter lies … Matthew Eliott (Vote Leave) appeared on Channel 4 News with some word salad about the fact that Brexit did deliver, except he could not explain how.

If you don’t have much time to dig deep, here’s a summary of the Brexit promises versus reality.

Hard Brexit Labour

Andy Burnham has already nailed himself to the mast of Brexit by stating that Labour’s red lines must remain and that he will not relitigate Brexit, despite being wildly out of synch with the ‘will of the people’. I fear that he too will be consumed by Brexit and have made a new Hannibal Lecter t-shirt to predict his downfall. Mail me reboot@brexitrage.com to get yours.

But, compared with Starmer, Burnham is more pliable / chameleon like. He could turn once he gets to grips with the hard facts of Brexit as Prime Minister. Especially if he gives Wes Streeting a top job. We’ll have to see.

The Wasted Years

I’ll be updating the book we wrote soon, with new contributions from former MEP Michael Hindley, Dr Charlie Clutterbuck and others. Working title is “Brexit – The Wasted Years’

Together Alliance

April Brexit Fools

Well, it’s not April Fools’ Day, so you’ve already fallen into my trap … Nonetheless, the tomfoolery of Trump and Brexit continues in a world where its increasingly hard to know the difference between fact, fiction and fantasy. Here’s a sobering update on world events from our continuing activism. To help support our costs and further actions via lobbying MPs and so on please send us a tip via SUPPORT US.

Our work in world media

Dubai TV called for our views on Keir Starmer’s recent pivot towards Europe. Here is our video plus some out takes we made to prepare for the interview which was done at very short notice:

Credit where it’s due. Keir Starmer has FINALLY plucked up courage to face down the orange psychopath, perhaps, in part, because he no longer has people like Morgan McSweeney driving Downing Street’s agenda. That said, and it’s a VERY BIG IF, Starmer must match fine words with action and apply to Rejoin the EU FULLY as an urgent priority. It matters not how log the journey takes but we must begin NOW. I concur with the FT analysis that says that going back to Europe for yet more concessions will be met with a dull bureaucratic thud of entropy.

Article content
Extract from FT article.

Grab copies of our book on Rejoining the EU and send to MPs and influencers. Written by 60 people and recently updated to address Trump 2.0. Proven to move the dial on Brexit with movers and shakers. Also valuable in shifting minds with people who still believe that Nigel Farage has answers to Reboot Britain. Hard copies and Kindle version available direct via Amazon and other bookshops. Author discount copies available via email reboot@brexitrage.com

Article content
Acclaimed by Michael Heseltine and Lord Newby amongst others …

Our work on the street

I attended the Together Alliance March on Saturday 28 March, with the single objective of getting a copy of the book to Billy Bragg. Mission accomplished !! Please get in touch with the bard of Barking to remind him of the book which aligns with much of Billy’s own thinking on England’s septic isle, poisoned by Brexit inspired racism, but which has always been there.

Billy Bragg
There is power in a union … With the bard of Barking. The Rt Hon Billy Bragg.

Billy performed three songs at the event. One I remember from seeing him at Harlesden and at “Red Wedge” from his early work:

Another poignant piece about the recent killings of innocent citizens in Minneapolis. This is matched by my own rendition of David Bowie’s “Where are We Now?” in honour of Renee Good and Alex Pritti, murdered by Donald J(anus) Trump.

And finally, here’s Billy’s 2000 piece he produced with Wilco, based on the words of Woody Guthrie about fascism, which sadly seems more prescient than ever. They shall not pass …

Five ways to defeat Brexit inspired fascism

All of us are able to act in smaller or larger ways to defeat the rise of Brexit and now Trump inspired fascism as outlined on our webpage: Rage Against The Brexit Machine aka Reboot Britain. Please SUPPORT our continuing work. We can only do this with your help. We do not have the luxury of subscriptions like the larger enterprises, the bank of goodwill is empty, and trips to MP constituencies / Parliament and so on cost money.

ger islands within our “Indonesian structure” such as The European Movement. I am told that we achieve far more impact through the targeting of influential people, via one to many MSM communications and daily acts of “Brexorcism”. Small can be beautiful in the wake of our unwillingness to resolve the structural, leadership and OD (Organisational Development) deficit of our “17 000 islands”. Here are the five ways you can act on a daily basis to end Brexit (and Trumpian) populism:

Reboot Britain Goals
Daily practice is necessary to defeat NF, DJT and his stormtroopers around the world …
Break Brexit Before Brexit Breaks Britain
From an original New Year’s Resolution in the shower January 1st 2017.
Reboot Britain banner

A vision for a Better Britain

I’ve prepared this vision in advance of a leaders’ debate on Tuesday May 26 via ZOOM from 19.00 – 20.30 hours with someone who still believes that Brexit was a good idea. Please mail me to join this major event via reboot@brexitrage.com Thanks to Celia Morris, Sean Hodges, Klara Goldy, Robert Anthony, Greg Newman, Tessa Tiley and Helga Perry for their help in compiling this list. To support our costs in running the event please go to SUPPORT US.

For an amusing aside to one of the many failed attempts to get a Brexit supporter to attend, see our private e-mail exchanges with Steve Horton, leader of “Logical Politics”, a group which aim to bring the far right into a harmonious fighting corp, including the BNP, who may as well be described as a proscribed terrorist organisation. Anyway, on with the positive vision.

A better Britain in a better Europe for a better World

I want to live in a country where I can drink clean water, eat fresh food and embrace the diversity of British culture, from curries to chips, chops, kebabs, chinese and way beyond.

I want to welcome strangers here and help them contribute to society.

I want to be friends with our European cousins and remove all the social, political and legal barriers created by Brexit.

I want to live without fear of losing my human and workers’ rights and extend this courtesy to all who visit our country.

I want Britain to be a gold standard bearer for upholding the rule of law.

I want to live in a country with leaders who respect our environment and the welfare of the other species who share it with us.

I want to Rejoin the EU fully, not a bundle of half measures.
I want freedom with responsibility not freedom to hurt others.

I want to push back on bullies. This is not who we are.

I want Britain to lead the way on measures to combat climate disaster.

I want Britain to put vulnerable people first. The elderly, children and the infirm.

I want to know that timely and effective treatment for any ill, condition or ailment that befalls me is conveniently available, freely and without delay, anywhere in the land.

I want a fair wage for a decent day’s work and worker’s rights that match those offered to workers in Europe.

I want women to be treated fairly based on knowledge, skills and experience rather than patronised or sidelined.

I want Britain to get back on the road to sustainable growth.

I want a sustainable energy sector that is the property of the people, not shareholders.

I want a transport network that works for the people, not for profit takers, and one that helps us reduce our addiction to the infernal combustion engine.

I want our politics to be inclusive via the setting up of citizens’ assemblies and other hallmarks of a participative democracy.

I want my vote to count more than it does currently in our broken electoral system.

I want our children to be able to live, love and work in Europe freely.

I want Britain to develop food security, something we have gradually lost since WWII.

I want to live in a country that celebrates the arts, maintains our artistic heritage and invests in our artistic and cultural future.

I want us to put education to help people learn continuously, become emotionally literate and decode truth from misinformation to be at the heart of British culture.

I want a health service that is free to all at the point of use.

I want our Government to take action on large enterprises who do not pay their fair share of tax.

I want Britain to lead in technology, science, hard and soft engineering and AI, but not be slaves to machine learning.

I want to live in a country where respect for every generation is a virtuous circle.

I want our police to be more interested in preventing and dealing with serious crime rather than acting as tax collectors for the government.

I want people who go to prison to come out better than when they went in.

I want immigrants to experience our culture and feel so welcomed and inspired by it that they willingly choose to embrace it and become British.

I want a country that celebrates all faiths.

I want social cohesion to be actively cultivated through integration, participation, shared education, and communities that genuinely mix rather than live separately alongside one another.

I want investment put back into Britain’s towns, services, infrastructure, education, and communities so people feel there is stability, dignity, and opportunity again.

Mail us at reboot@brexitrage.com for your ticket

Epstein

Oh Mandy

Kier Starmer offered a dignified and full apology yesterday over his appointment of “Mandelstein” or “Mandy”. Subject to transparency via the investigation, that is sufficient in my view. Why do I say that, you may well ask?
Starmer actually sacked Mandy where others did not. He has persuaded M to step down as a Lord. In due course and subject to there being sufficient evidence, Mandy will be prosecuted and possibly jailed. Later on we are likely to see similar outcomes with Michelle Mone and others. All takes time, but the law moves at a very slow pace. Farage law is not a suitable replacement for the rule of law as some CONform nutjobs suggest (“Farage Law” amounts to saying “Your eyes are too close together” or “You have a bit of a tan … GO TO JAIL”).

James O’Brien asked the question why did we not know all of this when Mandy was appointed as “Ferrero Rocher Ambassador and Defence Against The Dark TrumPutin Arts” to face down Trump in 2025. I was in fact one person who did predict that this appointment would end in tears in time – it was not a question of if but when. If you work in HR, one normally has a list of essential and desirable qualities plus contra-indications for your selection process. Mandy did possess some qualities which will have been judged as postives, and I suspect that McSweeney et al did not use my checklist below to look at the massive list of contra-indications. Starmer’s weakness is perhaps that he listened to McSweeney. It’s a forgiveable leadership sin, especially when weighed against the actions that Starmer has now taken to rectify the error. I say this objectively as someone who is not a massive Starmer fan. At the time, we must remember that we were beleagured by Brexit, and therefore wanting to be friends with ANYONE and EVERYONE on the international stage. Although it’s not clever, I think I understand why Starmer may have come to the conclusion that Mandy was an essential evil to tame the 5 Ts : Trump’s Toddler (Todger !!) Temper Tantrums. Although I very much doubt that proper HR processes were used, a sober analysis of the situation may have revealed the looming problem of Mandelstein to those possessed with hubris when advising / lobbying Keir Starmer.

HR selection grid - Peter Mandelstein

Dear Keir

Starmer stood up for decency and the rule of law yesterday and, for that, I give him a free pass. That said, it comes with some Terms and Conditions:

Morgan McSweeney must go. He is the architect of much of this and will have lobbied Starmer to accept Mandy, having also persuaded him to oust Sue Gray for opposing him.

Credit where it's due. Well done to Keir Starmer for removing Morgan McSweeney from Downing Street. I'm no fan of Keir but he has done what none of the others would have done. If he gets Mandelson banged up, he will cast a shadow on the populists around the world. Still more to do but good show.

— Peter Cook: Brexorcist in Chief: Reboot Britain (@brexitrage.bsky.social) 2026-02-08T22:23:36.334Z

Brexit must be ended as a priority, not in 2032, as some Labour MPs suggest. Fix the fundamentals as Keir likes to say a lot. Brexit lies at the heart of a lot of Britain’s problem as our Brexit Iceberg shows

Policy making which prays to the far right fascist fringe must stop. Remember, 90% of Reform accounts are bots. Many of Starmer’s bad decisions have been aimed at appeasement of the far right. It is ALWAYS a mistake to appease fascists.

More should be made of the good works that Labour are doing. This is a comms issue, which once again lies at McSweeney’s door.

Mainstream media

I was shoe horned onto LBC at 11.57 today (Fri 6 Feb) (thank you by the way) to try to explain all of this in ‘just a minute’. Find the playback on the LBC app or here on our radio interviews with MSM:

Click the image to listen to the LBC segment on our bandcamp page.

My friend Dr Raj Persaud also made this superb piece of analysis on the matter of Mandy.

Turn despair into action

Write to your MP, enclosing a hard copy of our book Brexit RIP, written by 60 British and European citizens, including two MEPs, a KC and many eminent experts .. Hard copy books have a much longer “social journey” than bleating about it on social media. They get passed around and so on. Gift copies to your circle of contacts, especially those soft leavers who are starting to doubt the idea that Brexit was a sticking plaster for all of our problems, and Rejoiners who consider the matter closed for a host of reasons. Relight the fire.

Hard copies have a much better ‘social journey’ than e-mail. Much better for MPs, influencers and social contacts.

Also on Kindle for personal use.

Epstein
Reboot Britain : Rejoin EU
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.